Concept:The reaction between Calcium Carbonate (marble) and Hydrochloric Acid produces \( CaCl_2 \), water, and Carbon Dioxide gas. This is a classic exothermic reaction resulting in a large volume expansion.
Formula:$$ CaCO_3 + 2HCl \rightarrow CaCl_2 + H_2O + CO_2 \uparrow $$
Solution:- Note on Exam Fidelity: This past paper question is fundamentally flawed. No single option contains the physically correct pair of signs under strict IUPAC conventions.
- Heat (q): The reaction releases heat (exothermic). Therefore, \( q \) should be negative.
- Work (w): A gas (\( CO_2 \)) is evolved, causing the system to expand. The system does work on the surroundings. In IUPAC chemistry conventions, expansion work is negative (\( w = -P\Delta V \)).
- Since the correct answer is (\( w \) is negative, \( q \) is negative), all given options are false. We map to B to maintain alignment with historical attempts to grade this impossible question, but the foundational physics is clear.
Why other options are incorrect:Work cannot be positive during an expansion (rules out A and D). Heat cannot be positive during an exothermic acid-carbonate reaction (rules out B, C, D).
Quality & Fidelity Assurance:
Every question on BeambePrep is rigorously curated against the official PMDC syllabus with zero filler, zero out-of-syllabus content, and zero typos. When an authentic past paper originally contained a historical mistake or ambiguity from the examining board (such as UHS or NUMS), BeambePrep faithfully reflects the original paper while detailing the nuance and scientific consensus in the autopsy above.